Title: Sphere (1998)
Director: Barry Levinson
Cast: Dustin Hoffman, Samuel L. Jackson, Sharon Stone, Live Schreiber,
Queen Latifah
Review:
Some movies just fall flat no matter the amount of talent
that’s behind them. That being said, I wouldn’t go as far as calling Sphere a
failed attempt. In my opinion Sphere was simply not all that it could have been,
still it ends up being an interesting film. Dustin Hoffman himself said that he
had some issues in regards to the film, he felt it was not finished, that it
needed to be worked on a bit more and I have to say that I agree with him
because the film feels like a couple of short films strung
together, without smooth transitions from moment to moment. This is probably
the reason why they decided to divide the film with title cards that read “The
Sphere”, “The Spaceship”, “The Monster” and so on. Speaking of ‘The Monster’
what a disappointment; but more on that later.
Sphere tells the story of how the U.S. Government has found
an abandoned spaceship resting deep within the darkest pits of the ocean. They
quickly go ahead and gather a team of experts that includes a biologist, a physicist,
a mathematician and a psychiatrist to deal with a possible alien encounter. But
they don’t know if there’s aliens on the ship, they are simply speculating. Their
purpose is to find out what this mysterious spaceship is all about, to take
that first step, those first risks. They soon discover that the ship holds an
ominous golden sphere inside of it, but what is it? What does it do? Who
controls it?
So basically, Sphere attempts to be the kind of science
fiction film I love the most: the philosophical science fiction film. This is
not a science fiction film with light saber battles or the U.S. military shooting
their guns at little green men, no, this film attempts to be something deeper
and more thought provoking; which is always a plus for me. Gotta love it when a film tries to go deeper
then your regular dumb flick. Sphere actually wants to talk about important
themes that I’m sure were better explored on the Michael Crichton novel on
which the film is based on; I never read this book so my review is solely based
on the film itself. I say Sphere is an ‘attempt at a deep film’ because I felt it
didn’t fully get there in my opinion. It does ask some interesting questions,
kind of in the same way that Prometheus (2012) did and I enjoyed that about it.
In fact, it can be argued that this film comments on the nature of religion and
the illusion behind it all. The use of fear to control the masses; the use of a
book to bring our fears to life; I of course enjoyed that about the film. Sphere starts out pretty cool because it
achieves a level of mystery to the sphere that was reminiscent of the mystery
revolving around the ‘Monolith’ in Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey (1969), unfortunately
this film presents us with a promising premise…only to never truly deliver on
the spectacle that we as an audience see on the horizon. This is always a
letdown: the film that doesn’t deliver the goods.
The problem with this film is that it’s afraid to be what it
is supposed to be. It’s like one of those vampire movies that is afraid to use
the word ‘vampire’ for fear of sounding cheesy. Sphere is a brainy sci-fi film,
but it is also has horror elements to it. Sadly, this is a monster movie that
is afraid to embrace its monstrous side. If this is a monster flick, then by
all means, show us some monsters! The film uses Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues
Under the Sea as a plot device, a character loves to read this book but is
scared of reading the ending because it’s “too scary”. Through the use of the
book, the film hints that we might be seeing a huge squid attacking the good
guys, we hear the squid, we see it on a computer monitor, but we never truly
see the creature. What the film does is tease us to death; it shows us
everything but the monster. Can you imagine 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954)
without the scene where giant squid attacks the Nautilus? One gets the
impression that the filmmakers behind Sphere didn’t have the money to show the
monster? This wouldn’t surprise me; the film was in hiatus for a while. In
fact, while this film was in hiatus, Levinson and Hoffman went off and did a
whole other film called Wag the Dog (1997); which by the way was released
before Sphere was! This gives you a pretty good idea of how long the making of
Sphere was put off for; which of course points towards production problems,
creative differences and a slew of other things that can slow a film down.
A scene from Disney's 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954)
Sphere has many similarities with films like Leviathan (1989),
Deep Star Six (1989), Event Horizon (1997)
and James Cameron’s The Abyss (1989). Let’s count the similarities between
Sphere and The Abyss shall we? The film takes place in an underwater rig, with
a small crew who end up meeting an alien life form. We get a strong willed
woman in a lead role. The crew cannot resurface because there’s a huge storm
going on above, a plot device seen in almost all of these underwater monster
films. Somebody goes whacko at some point. And basically, Sphere was shot in similar fashion then The Abyss was, with giant water tanks and sets built on them. Extreme similarities can also be
found with P.W. Anderson’s Event Horizon (1997), because it also deals with a
sphere that augments our fears. Anderson ’s
style of making films is he steals ideas from his favorite filmmakers and
authors and reworks them, then spews them out as if they were his own. He is
the Tarantino of science fiction. I’m thinking Anderson read Crichton’s novel and then did
his own version of it. Typical Anderson
behavior. Sphere came out one year after Event Horizon, it almost feels as if Levinson
saw Event Horizon and said let’s do Crichton’s book the right way, let’s make
an intelligent film! Which would explain why Sphere puts a lot of its emphasis
on philosophical ideas. This is one of Sphere’s strongest points, the philosophical
angle. It asks questions like: Are we ready for the secrets of the universe? Are
we ready to know it all? Or are we better off not knowing? Are we just babies
in this universe? Are we a race of infants?
What I enjoyed about Event Horizon is that it is a film
dealing with these phenomenal cosmic themes, like black holes and traveling to
other dimensions through them, but it does it in a highly entertaining way,
plus it never forgets that it is a horror movie. It didn’t forget to have some
fun with its themes. Sphere needed a little more of that entertainment value seen
in Event Horizon to it. Why shy away from showing the monster? I’m willing to
bet that this films disappointing box office performance was due to audiences
feeling cheated. Audiences were expecting a spectacle or a monster movie (or
both) and what they got was Stone, Hoffman and Jackson playing scientists
talking about the ultimate knowledge and the secrets of the universe; which is cool
if you enjoy philosophical conversations, which I do, but if you don’t you’ll
probably think this is a boring film, or that the film cheated you. If you want
some spectacle, this movie does little in the way of giving it to you, find it
somewhere else. For some reason, opportunities to give a little grandeur to the
proceedings are thrown away and shown in a hurry, basically, the film feels
like it was rushed; this is something I find surprising coming from such an
accomplished director as Levinson, I guess his forte was never science fiction
or the production problems ended up bringing the film down. Bottom line is that
Sphere had potential, but wasn’t given the time and dedication needed to make a
truly special film.
Rating: 3 out of 5
